I found Caleb through his newest So True podcast. I cant express how absolutely hilarious he is. I caught up to all of the so true episodes and just NEEDED more. This podcast has been a beautiful combination of friendship, comedy, care, and endless possibilities. Well well well well well well well well :)

I miss this show big time. There are few podcasts where both cohosts are equally as funny, there’s always one that resonates more with the listener! I cannot overstate how funny Caleb and Shelby each are in their own right, but, somehow, some way, are exponentially funnier together. Is it a dumb premise for a podcast? Yes. Is it a genius premise for a podcast? Yes. Every episode kept you thinking about yourself and if you agree/disagree with the guest’s inclusions and always wondering: what would YOU add? I had an hour-each-way commute to work and this podcast SAVED me. Love you both and your careers! But RIP to the best show ever.

A great show where the two host cut the guest off and keep cutting each other off for a bit that's not even funny. 5 stars.

Doing my 3rd or 4th relisten…. Just miss you guys

perfection

Best podcast that’s ever been made. It’s the only one that needs to exist.

This podcast gave me an amazing conversation starter and soooo many laughs. I felt cool because I listened. And isn’t that what we all want? To feel cool?

The sadness I feel getting to the last episode and realizing this is actually the last episode of the podcast. Traumatized. Please come back, I need to have Shelby being unhinged in my life at least once a week. This podcast is 10/10 no notes. - A person with a terminal degree in their field.

i really miss you guys.

Thank you

thx 4 a good time

the pod is aging like a fine wine 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻

Arrived at this show via EJ, and I now can’t WAIT for new eps to cackle to while doing other tasks wherein I shouldn’t be cackling—like buying groceries with headphones in, because human interaction is, famously, for narcs. That said, please never get rid of EJ!!! I went back to older eps after blowing through the new ones and this show is genuinely intolerable prior to EJ joining. I’m not sure how the dynamic is so different in older eps, but with the old host it suddenly becomes the worst kind of loud, unfunny theater kids from your middle school who are inexplicably sweaty and unkempt, and only laughing at themselves. Shelby plays SO much better off of EJ and is 100% funnier. Even the guests shine more in the new eps. So keep it up and never look back friends!

i think i’ve listened to every episode at least three times and i still laugh just as hard as i did on my first listen. i try to tell everyone i know to listen to this and i look forward to every new episode each week. i adore the addition of EJ so much and the chemistry between them and Shelby is amazing 🤍

this is my most favorite podcast and the highlight i’ve of my fridays every week! i hope shelby is reading this from the comfort of her bed hey girly! ej is such a great edition to the show and i love all the guest they have on each week! if i could give them six starts, i would. love you shelby, ej, anya, and caleb (rest in peace)

wood woof woof woof

The premise is amazing and allows for a lot of hilarious and sometimes even heartfelt conversations. Shelby and Caleb are both iconic and so dang funny, and now I love EJ too!! The guests are great and all bring something new to the table!

Morro bay? Giant rock? Near Pismo and SLO?

Around 20 min into the latest ep y’all said mary Kate and Ashley never did a parent trap style movie…. I beg to differ and I present u with… It Takes Two… my fav childhood movie and a cinematic masterpiece. Anyways! Love the pod you guys are great! Keep up the good work Also I am fully acknowledging that it’s annoying of me to correct you all about this but it’s genuinely because I want you to watch the movie!!

This is my review of this funny podcast

Shelby is queen

This podcast is my favorite!!! It’s hilarious, charming, authentic and really will be helpful when the aliens do listen in.

We were nervous with no Caleb BUT it still works! E.J we love, Shelby rising star 💖

EJ is a great addition to the pod.

absolutely no notes, completely perfect // update per todays episode… I absolutely fall asleep to all episodes lol so I got you

LOVE THIS POD! ❤️

Todays ep had me lit rally laughing out loud. Rip Caleb BUT I’m loving the new vibe w Shelby and EJ. Shelb’s nj accent has somehow become the voice of my inner monologue whoops. Big love 🤍🤍🤍

Caleb might literally be the funniest person alive

Love!!!

tbh I just found this podcast in the last month and I have plenty of back episodes to go through. No free clout for the girlies but maybe if we are really good maybe some free clout as a treat? I like when Caleb is mean to Shelby but I don’t like when guest is mean to Shelby

^

this is my favorite podcast of all time and i would like to date shelby should the opportunity present itself

I love this thing. Started listening a week ago and have loved every single ep. Some of the funniest folks in the world!!!

truly sounded really good like someone really drove fast by the mic from

Caleb’s record is perfect and I agree with Shelby that the guy infiltrating the swimply was weird and he should be stopped. Also, im absolutely crushed the pod is ending

I might throw myself off of a building if I can’t hear them both weekly. Both Caleb and Shelby got me through some losses of my own in the past few months and I hate to be so dependent on their voices. I hope they have wonderful things to come or we can find them on a different format. 100000000 stars-thank you girlies.

This is my favorite podcast and such a groundbreaking concept. It actually brought me so much joy during a really rough time personally and globally but no worries that it’s coming to an end. I’m not even sad like at all. I will be putting Keeping Records on my golden record.

I started listening last week as a thought-to-be cishet man but after bingeing every episode realizing I’m probably closer to being a gender fluid pansexual. Anyway, the pod rocks and every second is worth a listen!

It means the world to me. There will be consequences

I just found this podcast 3 weeks ago and now it’s already over!!! 😭😭😭 Shelby and Caleb are so funny and I wish them the best in their endeavors. Willing to pay for podcast content!!!!!

Caleb and Shelby filled the queer, unhinged hole in my little freak life that was previously filled by Urgent Care. DEVASTATED to lose another show that is so perfectly cuckoo and also poignant. i hope to see and hear them around some of my other favorite podcasts because the energy is too good to go unobserved. also losing this and Joe Pera in the same week is an active war crime. (p.s. i feel like the production team really did them dirty in the last couple of months)

I’ve listened to each ep multiple times and this is my favorite podcast by far. Despite this fact, I haven’t written a review until now. I can’t help but make the pod ending about me- maybe if I had done my five star review earlier, none of this would be happening. Shelby and Caleb, thank you so much. You both share the #1 comedian spot in my heart. I live in Utah but hope to see y’all’s shows in the future. ❤️ from a straight little freak (yes we exist)

but find it very hot when y’all talk about it

…that WILL be around forever.

This podcast is everything. Caleb and Shelby are Gods. They are my rudders on the stormy sea that is my life and all our lives. Sincerely, One of the straight little freaks - yes, we do exist

My partner and I love for this podcast. We stay cracking up.

You’ve mentioned a few times that you have really educated lil freaks and I know a large population of scientists (including me) listen to podcasts while doing mind numbing tasks like data analysis or cell culture. This podcast is the most entertaining one I've listened to by far. But I give it 4 stars because I was so excited for the episode that Vinny was a guest on and you guys barely let him speak :( except to say he doesn't want aliens to know we drink milk

I love this podcast so much. I listen to it religiously and will re-listen to episodes when I’m feeling lonely and want to feel like I am around friends which, to me, is a major purpose of a podcast. Each guest they have on is not only funny, but completely unpretentious and down for the ride. Caleb and Shelby are extremely talented and have such a solid and entertaining rapport. Would love to become a full time Little Freak for these girlies. Cannot recommend enough

I would send this podcast to space for the aliens.

this is the best pod in the world xx and i HATE to be real in reviews folks, but it’s so nice to hear two besties goof around and ultimately, be deeply and passionately in love w each other! there i said it